In NXT, he is one of three men (the other two men being The Revival's Scott Dawson and Dash Wilder) to win the NXT Tag Team Championship twice, with his first reign being one-half of the inaugural champions with Oliver Grey and the other reign with Corey Graves. He is also a one-time NXT Champion, thus making him the first (and only) man to have held both the NXT Championship and the NXT Tag Team Championship. Neville was called onto the main roster in 2015 and was later drafted to Raw in the 2016 draft. He went on to win his first main roster title in 2017 by defeating Rich Swann for the Cruiserweight Championship at the 2017 Royal Rumble. He made his WrestleMania debut the same year, successfully defending the championship against Austin Aries.